A beige corded telephone, a brass room key, and a lit bedside lamp on a motel nightstand

Yes. Aileen Wuornos had a girlfriend, Tyria Moore. They met in 1986 at a gay bar in the Daytona Beach area and lived together for about four and a half years. In January 1991, after Wuornos was arrested, Moore helped police record the phone calls that led to her confession. Moore was never charged with any crime in the case.

Moore is also the real person behind Selby Wall, the character Christina Ricci plays in the 2003 film Monster. Here is what the court record and dated news reports say about Moore and Aileen Wuornos, what the movie changed, and what is public about Moore's life now.

If you are here after watching one of the new Wuornos shows, Serial Killer Shop has an Aileen Wuornos collection with shirts, hoodies, socks, and a mug.

Timeline of Tyria Moore and Aileen Wuornos from their meeting in June 1986 to the film Monster in 2003, with the December 1989 admission, the January 1991 recorded calls, and Moore's January 1992 testimony marked in red

How Tyria Moore and Aileen Wuornos met

Biography.com recalled the evening this way: "In June 1986, Wuornos, now calling herself 'Lee,' met 24-year-old Tyria Moore at a gay bar in Daytona, Florida." A Sun-Sentinel feature from November 17, 1991, names the bar as the Zodiac, in South Daytona, and says Moore came from a middle-class family in Cadiz, Ohio. Wuornos was 30. She later described Moore as "the love of my life," the Los Angeles Times reported.

Many retellings, including an older version of this page, say they met in a biker bar. That is a mix-up. The biker bar in this story is the Last Resort in Port Orange, where Wuornos was arrested in 1991.

Before Moore, Wuornos had been married once, to Lewis Fell, in 1976. That marriage ended within weeks. Our article on Aileen Wuornos's son covers the Fell marriage and the baby she gave up for adoption in 1971.

Life together in motels and trailers

The Florida Supreme Court's 1994 opinion in the Mallory case puts it plainly: "Tyria Moore and Aileen Wuornos lived together as lovers for about four and a half years. Moore worked as a maid, while Wuornos worked as a prostitute along Central Florida highways." The Los Angeles Times wrote that the couple "lived in rooms and motels." In March 1989 they rented a trailer in Homosassa, according to the Sun-Sentinel.

"We became lovers," Moore told police, "and it later turned into a sisterlike relationship." Wuornos, the same Sun-Sentinel report says, told people that Ty was her wife.

Retellings often say Moore didn’t approve of the sex work. The dated sources we could check do not quote her on it. Biography.com says only that Wuornos was possessive and did not like it when Moore went to work or spent time with other people.

Wuornos also had trouble with the police during these years. Between 1987 and 1988, police questioned her at least three times, over a man hit with a beer bottle, damage to an apartment, and phone calls to a supermarket, according to the case summary on Murderpedia. None of those contacts is part of the murder case.

What Tyria Moore knew about the murders

Wuornos was convicted of murdering Richard Mallory, the first of the killings. According to the 1994 opinion, on December 1, 1989, Wuornos came back to the Volusia County motel where she and Moore were living and "told Moore that she had shot and killed a man early that morning." A year later she confessed the murder to police on videotape.

Moore's story, as the Sun-Sentinel reported it in 1991, was that Wuornos told her about the first killing in December 1989 and that she refused to talk about it again. In other words, she didn’t want to know more. About the property Wuornos brought home, Moore "claimed she thought it was all just what Wuornos had taken in trade from her johns," the paper wrote. The same report says: "There are no charges against Moore in the killings. Police accept her claim that she was never directly involved."

The car that led police to both women

Peter Siems, a 65-year-old missionary, went missing in 1990. His body has never been found, and Wuornos was never charged with his death. The 1994 opinion says: "Law officers later found Siems' car in Orange Springs on July 4, 1990. Witnesses identified Tyria Moore and Aileen Wuornos as the two persons seen leaving the car." A witness, Rhonda Bailey, saw two women climb out of the car. A palm print on the inside door handle matched Wuornos.

Tips led to a composite drawing of the two women, the Los Angeles Times reported. Moore saw the news coverage. The court opinion says she "became afraid, left Wuornos, and returned to her home up north."

The arrest and the recorded phone calls

On January 9, 1991, Wuornos was arrested at the Last Resort bar in Port Orange on an outstanding warrant. Officers then contacted Moore in Pennsylvania. Biography.com says she "made a deal to gather evidence against Wuornos in order to avoid prosecution," and the court opinion says she "agreed to return to Florida in an attempt to clear herself of any wrongdoing."

Back in Florida, police put Moore up in a Daytona Beach motel room for four days and tape-recorded 10 phone calls between the two women, the Los Angeles Times reported in December 1991. At a court hearing that month, Moore admitted that she lied, cried, and pleaded with Wuornos to get her to talk about the killings. Wuornos tried to protect her. In one call she told Moore: "I will not let you be involved in the picture. You're not the one. I am the one who did everything. I did it all myself."

On January 16, 1991, Aileen confessed on videotape. In upholding her conviction in 1994, the Florida Supreme Court wrote that Moore "encouraged Wuornos to confess and did so in part because of Moore's own fears of being prosecuted as an accomplice," and that the calls "may have contained misstatements and exaggerations by both parties." Moore also later showed officers where to find the gun.

Tyria Moore's testimony at the Mallory trial

Tyria Moore answering questions at a courtroom microphone

At the Mallory trial in January 1992, Tyria described to the jury how Wuornos came home and told her she had killed a man. On January 27, 1992, the jury convicted Wuornos of first-degree murder. She was sentenced to death four days later.

Wuornos then pleaded no contest or guilty in five more killings and received six death sentences in all. She was executed at Florida State Prison on October 9, 2002. You can read what she said in court and on that last day in our collection of Aileen Wuornos quotes.

Was Selby Wall real? Tyria Moore in Monster

Selby Wall is not a real person, but she is based on one. In Monster (2003), written and directed by Patty Jenkins, Christina Ricci plays Selby Wall, whom Biography.com calls "a character inspired by Tyria Moore." Charlize Theron plays Wuornos and won the Academy Award for Best Actress for the role.

Charlize Theron as Aileen Wuornos and Christina Ricci as Selby Wall at a bar in the 2003 film Monster

Instead of using Moore's name, the film created a new character, and Wikipedia calls Selby a semi-fictionalized version of Moore. That gave the filmmakers room to change things. So if you are asking whether Selby was real, the answer is this: the name is invented, the relationship is real, and the film does not follow the court record scene by scene.

Who plays Tyria Moore in the Netflix Monster series?

No one, as far as the official cast list shows. Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story premiered on Netflix on September 17, 2026, with Sarah Paulson as Wuornos. Netflix's cast guide describes Wuornos as a drifter who finds solace in Lizzie Borden's story. It does not list a Tyria Moore character.

Investigation Discovery's three-part series Unmasking a Monster premieres on September 30, 2026, with Morag Peacock as Wuornos. The Realscreen announcement does not name Moore. We have not seen the episodes, so we cannot say how the series covers her.

Tyria Moore now

Moore has stayed out of public view since the 1992 trial. None of the sources we checked record her giving an interview, writing a book, or taking part in a film about the case. Some websites claim to know where she lives and who she lives with. We could not confirm any of it from a reliable, dated source. She is a private person who was never charged, so we do not repeat it.

Some retellings also say Moore was from Pennsylvania. The 1991 Sun-Sentinel report says she came from Cadiz, Ohio. She was in Pennsylvania when police reached her in January 1991.

If you want Wuornos's own version of these years, her book with Christopher Berry-Dee is Monster: My True Story. It is her account, and it does not always match the court record.

Tyria Moore FAQ

Did Aileen Wuornos have a girlfriend?

Yes. Her girlfriend was Tyria Moore. They met in June 1986 at a gay bar in the Daytona area and were together for about four and a half years, until Moore left Florida, before Wuornos's arrest in January 1991.

Was Tyria Moore charged with a crime?

No. Police accepted her account that she was not directly involved in the killings, and she helped them get Wuornos's confession.

Was Selby Wall a real person?

No. Selby Wall is the name the film Monster (2003) gave to a character based on Tyria Moore. Christina Ricci played her.

Did Tyria Moore testify against Aileen Wuornos?

Yes. She testified at the January 1992 trial for the murder of Richard Mallory, which ended in a conviction and a death sentence.

Where is Tyria Moore now?

That is not public in any reliable source. She has not spoken publicly about the case since the trial.

Are you a true crime fanatic? Check out our limited edition serial killer clothing and the Aileen Wuornos collection (not for the faint of heart!)

As an Amazon Associate, Serial Killer Shop earns from qualifying purchases made through the Amazon links on this page.

*Images from Liveabout, Pinterest, Biography and Zimbio

You may also like

The 7 Most Famous Women Serial Killers

Aileen Wuornos's Son: The Child She Gave Up in 1971

Aileen Wuornos Quotes and Her Last Words

The 7 Worst Teenage Serial Killers

Our list of famous female serial killers covers the other women in this history.

Sources

  • Supreme Court of Florida. Wuornos v. State, 644 So. 2d 1000, opinion filed September 22, 1994. law.justia.com.
  • MacNamara, Mark. "Death Thumbs a Ride." Sun-Sentinel, November 17, 1991. sun-sentinel.com.
  • Clary, Mike. "A Mother's Love." Los Angeles Times, December 17, 1991. latimes.com.
  • Biography.com. "Aileen Wuornos." Updated October 29, 2025. biography.com.
  • Wikipedia. "Aileen Wuornos" and "Monster (2003 film)." Accessed September 28, 2026. en.wikipedia.org.
  • Netflix Tudum. "Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story cast guide." Accessed September 28, 2026. netflix.com.
  • Realscreen. "ID slates Aileen Wuornos docuseries featuring VFX recreations." July 22, 2026. realscreen.com.

96 comments

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published